Turn Data into Revenue: Steps for Monitoring and Recovering Utility Costs
by Jim Linehan, Vice President Operations, June 2003Building owners and managers today are
overburdened with the complexity of
purchasing electric power and properly
billing tenants for power use. As tenants'
power requirements increase and the
regulatory and rate structures become
increasingly complex, it is necessary for
owners and managers to fully understand
how to charge each tenant.
The essential need to first reconcile
utility bills and then calculate charges for
each tenant is often stymied by an avalanche
of confusing rules, rates, and end
user surcharges. To make matters worse,
many buildings have obsolete or unreliable
metering systems to track data.
So, how can an owner begin to take
control of this key cost area? To ensure
that revenue is maximized and tenants
are equitably treated, it is imperative that
two areas are expertly managed—the
physical layers, which deliver and measure
power (the electric distribution and
metering system) and the business layers,
which provide the rules for allocating costs
(lease and regulatory language). Using
an integrated approach that addresses
both of these areas ensures that accurate
consumption data captured by
the meters will be used to bill tenants in
compliance with their lease language.
A strategic business view of these
issues, coupled with a clear understanding
of the regulatory environment and
energy pricing models, will help maximize
a building's value. To the extent
that energy costs are accurately allocated
to tenants, owners and managers can
significantly reduce their operating
expenses and improve the financial
performance of their buildings. Keep
in mind that a dollar increase in revenue
or decrease in expenses can equal a
$10 increase in asset value.
Attracting and Keeping
the Best Tenants
Building owners and managers naturally
want to retain and attract quality
tenants. To do this, you must be able to
show that you can pass through any
expense reduction, and that all power
expenses are being equitably distributed
to all tenants. A reliable and sophisticated
metering system is essential. Less sophisticated
systems that do not consider a
more strategic view result in lost revenue
or having to back bill tenants.
Your physical system must be
properly connected to the data layer
of your metering system. If everything
is not configured correctly, you could
easily be overcharged by the utility
company, or inaccurately charging
your tenants. In either case, the
revenue drain can be substantial.
A Metering System Is
Not Enough
Additionally, simply having a metering
system does not guarantee that it is
collecting the right data. It is important
that you apply a disciplined approach to
the implementation and management
of your metering systems. At a utility, the
meter is analogous to a "cash register."
The meter is the point-of-sale. If proper
planning and care is not taken in the implementation, then the "cash
register" may be leaking value from
the business.
Metering "leakage" can be a major
problem, costing 5–10% (or much
more in some exceptional cases) of
your annual power bill. For example,
in one downtown office building, the
metering system was so poorly configured
it showed power flowing in the
wrong direction and over-counting the
consumption, resulting in a total lack of
confidence in the data. Without the data
to justify tenant bills, the owner was left
with the choice of estimating consumption
(guessing) or even worse "eating
the cost." If configuration problems
such as this are left unfixed or if your
meters need to be reset, you could not
only lose valuable historic data but also
the confidence of your tenants.
Verifying that your system is properly
logging energy usage and that the configuration
is accurately measuring your
usage is the first step in uncovering the
hidden value within your building.
Many Steps Contribute to
Bottom Line
A strategic view of energy consumption
can result in peak shaving, or a reduction
in your peak period electrical load,
through energy conservation measures.
A careful evaluation can also show that
load shifting, or shifting your power consumption
to the least expensive periods,
can save you substantial energy dollars.
Understanding the intricacies of
energy consumption in your building
is only one component of the strategic
equation. It is also important to be
knowledgeable about the regulatory
environment in your area and the specific
rate structure of your utility company.
Working with the power company to negotiate
a more favorable deal and to identify
savings opportunities is recommended.
As with any negotiation, a good relationship
with the power company can
be very helpful. With careful analysis and
negotiation, you can save up to 10% on
power procurement and save on peak
usage charges. Initial buy opportunity
analysis, and ongoing market tracking
and commodity procurement, can ensure
that you are getting the best possible
deal from your utility company.
In addition, bill verification, cash flow
tracking, and capacity management
will positively affect the bottom line.
But, keeping up with everything can be
difficult. Seeking outside help on the
engineering opportunities and the financial
know-how mentioned above may be
the fastest path to bottom line savings.
Once there is a full understanding of
how power is being utilized in your building
and the best deal has been reached
with the utility company, you can look at
your current tenant leases. With verified
data and analysis, it is a lot easier to justify
lease changes, time usage data changes,
and back billing, if necessary.
If specific analysis shows you have
been improperly billing your current
tenants, a thorough analysis provides
the back up necessary to justify any back
billing. Having a third party to negotiate
with your tenants gives the process
a more objective dialogue and relates a
sense of openness to tenants affected
by billing changes.
When you add up all the potential
savings from the various stages of an
engineering and a strategic business
analysis, the benefits—in enhanced
revenue and decreased costs—increase
the value of your asset enough to justify
the investment in setting up a quality
tracking and billing system.