Electrical Arc Flash: Why Should I Care?
This paper is prepared to give a nonengineering
description of Electrical
Arc Flash. The hazards associated with
an Electrical Arc Flash can be significant
resulting in equipment damage,
loss of production, bodily harm or
even death. This paper is arranged as
a series of typical questions and their
associated answers.
What is an Electrical Arc Flash?
An Electrical Arc Flash is defined as
a condition when electric current
passes through ionized gases in
the air. Everybody is familiar with
naturally occurring Electrical Arc
Flashes —lightning; our discussion
shall be confined to the unnaturally
occurring variety of Arc Flashes—electrical faults. The essential need to first reconcile
utility bills and then calculate charges for
each tenant is often stymied by an avalanche
of confusing rules, rates, and end
user surcharges. To make matters worse,
many buildings have obsolete or unreliable
metering systems to track data.
What causes Electrical Arc Flashes?
An Electrical Arc Flash occurs when
current flows through ionized gases
in the air between conductors. These
may be opposing phase conductors
and/or ground. This condition is
normally referred to as an electrical
fault or 'short circuit.'
Does every 'short circuit' produce
an Arc Flash?
No, electrical faults come in two
varieties. The first type of electrical
fault is known as a ‘bolted fault’. A
bolted fault occurs between solidly
connected conductors and simply
results in excessive current flowing
beyond the design limits of those
conductors. This type of fault can be
as simple as an overload or the result
of an installation error.
The second type of fault is an
'arcing fault.' An arcing fault occurs
when the distance between conductors
is reduced to the point where
the voltage present causes the air to
ionize and establish a path for the
current to flow. This type of fault
normally results from accidental
contact between conductors.
How long do Arcing Faults last?
Typically arcing faults have a duration
of 0.2 seconds or less, however,
based upon the available energy and
the condition and reliability of the
overcurrent protective device the arc
may be sustained until the distance
through the air the arc must travel
exceeds the ability of the ionized
gases to provide a current path.
What are the immediate effects
of an Arc Flash?- Intense light:
An arc flash produces a blinding
light, brighter than looking into the
sun, which may cause immediate
permanent or temporary vision loss.
- Thermoacoustic shock wave:
An arc flash produces a thermoacoustic
shock wave. Metallic
copper expands 67,000 times its
volume when transitioning between
a solid and gaseous state in an arc
flash. The shockwave can rupture
eardrums, collapse lungs or result
in severe impact injuries.
- Thermal impacts:
An arc flash can produce intense
heat. An electrical arc normally burns
at approximately 35,000 degrees F.
This thermal wave can melt adjacent
metal components, ignite flammable
clothing and result in 1st, 2nd, or
3rd degree burns.
- Liquid Metal High Velocity Debris:
An arc flash can expel molten metal
and debris at a high velocity resulting
in damage and injuries many
feet from the site of the arc flash.
- Toxic Gases:
An arc flash can produce toxic
gases from the decomposition of
the conductors and the burning of
insulation. The byproducts of this
combustion may include known
cancer causing agents.
- Mechanical Forces:
An arc flash may cause great
mechanical stress to be imposed
on the current carrying conductors
resulting in their dislocation and
contact with other conductors, thus
spreading the fault.
Can the use of Personal Protective
Equipment (PPE) prevent injuries?
The use of proper personal protective
equipment will mitigate the effects
of an arc flash, however, their use
may not eliminate the risks involved.
Serious injury or death may still occur
even when proper PPE is utilized.
Are there rules governing
Electrical Arc Flash protection?
YES! The federal government has
established rules for safe work
practices, they are listed as part of
the Occupational Safety and Health
Act (OSHA) 29 CFR 1910, it’s the law.
A voluntary standard also exists prepared
by the National Fire Protection
Association (NFPA). The standard
for Electrical Safety in the Workplace
is NFPA 70E.
Verifying that your system is properly
logging energy usage and that the configuration
is accurately measuring your
usage is the first step in uncovering the
hidden value within your building.
Who is responsible for Electrical
Arc Flash protection?
Everyone is responsible. The standards
indicate that responsibility has
'dual' ownership. In simple terms
this means that the owner, contractor
and employee may all share responsibility
equally.
How can the risk of Electrical Arc
Flash be reduced?
Shutdown and lockout all sources of
energy prior to proceeding with the
work. The standards allow for work
on energized conductors under very
specific situations only and economic
hardship is not a valid reason.
How can I comply with the
standards?
To comply with the standard you
must first know what you have.
An Electrical Hazard Survey of your
facility will include an inventory of
electrical equipment, a short circuit
& coordination study, labeling of
equipment and its location for degree
of risk and identification of the proper
PPE required to perform work on
energized conductors.
Can the effects of Electrical Arc
Flash be reduced?
Yes, several methodologies exist
to reduce the amount of energy
available or the time that energy
is available. These may include
changing fuses, modifying equipment
to separate conductors, increasing
ground impedance or increasing
circuit resistance.
Is this going to be expensive?Costs associated with complying
with the standards are going to be
relative to the size of the facility and
the type, condition and operating
voltage of the equipment involved.
The costs associated with a single
Arc Flash incident (no matter whose
fault) can easily reach the $1.5 million
mark in direct and indirect expenses.
No matter how large or complicated
the facility it will not approach that
order of magnitude, and besides
compliance with OSHA regulations
is not voluntary – IT’S THE LAW!